Reader Case: Canadian making USD

Wanderer
Follow Me
The US flag and Canadian flag. Original public domain image from Flickr

FIRECracker got me in a reader case mood, so I thought I’d get in on the fun too! Here we go!


Can I start off with THANK YOU for providing your investment workshop for free. It’s so refreshing to read your unconventional way of life, and how you achieved freedom through consistent dedicated efforts. I’m turning 32 this year, and your journey is truly so inspiring and something I look up to. I binge read your journey and investment workshop in one setting. I have a clearer path now, but more questions than ever.

Second, I’m embarrassed with my investment situation. Yes, I was a part of the crowd in 2021 who spent their money on crypto and BB and didn’t have any clue what was going on. I hold way too much cash, and want to develop a better strategy with investing. I’ve made a lot of mistakes, but I want to do better and take care of future me.

For work, I am a freelance business consultant, and all of my clients are US based. That also means as a Canadian living in Canada, I make USD. There isn’t a lot out there that covers this topic on how Canadians who make USD should invest it, and what the tax implications can mean for us. I convert my USD to CAD when it is in my favour, but now the exchange rate is down to 1.35 (from 1.39) and I find myself reluctant to convert to CAD lately.

I moved a big chunk of USD into my TFSA. I think that may have been a mistake as I am subject to the 15% withholding tax. After reading your blog, I plan to max out my TFSA and RRSP as well as DCA all my cash in the next 6 months into ETFs. The investment advisor I spoke with suggested that I search for corporate class ETFs in USD so I’m not subject to the 15% withholding tax on dividends in my TFSA. The returns are not great and higher MERs. What are your thoughts on corporate class ETFs?

Also, money market funds – I currently use CASH.TO, PSA.TO for CAD and considering HSUV, HISU.U and PSU.U  for my USD. While I DCA into ETFs, I have an idea to move all into these funds so at least I don’t lose value on inflation. Thoughts on this?

I read your blog post where you touched briefly on Canadians who have a lot of foreign cash, and how you recommend using an Ultrashort. That article was back in 2019. Do you still recommend the same? Or stick with money market instead as it appears to have a higher yield YTD.

CanadianMakingUSD


This reader case is something that I can speak to directly, since I’m also in this situation. Because nearly all the income I make from this blog and our book gets paid to us in USD, our own personal finances is a mix of CAD and USD.

So we have some experience dealing with dual-currency investment portfolios. Let’s dive in, shall we?

Our Portfolio

You may have noticed, but we really like Questrade. Not only is their fee structure really low, one of the really nice features of their platform is that each account can hold both CAD and USD side-by-side. And I can transfer CAD to and from a CAD-denominated checking account, as well as USD from a USD-denominated checking account without forcing me to convert anything.

Inside Questrade, we have different accounts like TFSA’s, RRSPs, LIRAs, and taxable trading accounts. Here’s where tax optimization becomes super important, because as our reader noted, US-domiciled ETFs have special taxation considerations around withholding taxes depending on what kind of account they’re held in.

Income paid from a US-domiciled ETF like VTI are subject to a 15% withholding tax. If the ETF is held in taxable account, the 15% withholding tax is reported as a foreign tax credit on our tax slips that we get at the end of the year. These foreign tax credits are designed to offset any taxes we pay to a foreign government when we file our taxes, so as long as your Canadian tax bill is greater than the amount that got withheld, the net result is that our total tax bill will come out the be the same as if the 15% withholding tax was never charged at all.

Canada and the US also has a tax treaty that gives special treatment to RRSPs. Because the IRS recognizes these accounts as a tax-deferred retirement account similar to a 401(k), no withholding tax is charged at all.

However, the tax treaty doesn’t mention the TFSA, since the TFSA didn’t exist when the treaty was signed. So if a US-domiciled ETF is held in a TFSA, the 15% withholding tax is withheld as if it’s a taxable account. And to make matters worse, investments held in TFSAs don’t generate tax slips (since they’re supposed to be tax-free), so we can’t claim a tax credit for the withheld tax. When it comes to US ETFs, the TFSA is the worst of both worlds.

CanadianMakingUSD mentioned something called Corporate class funds, which are a specialized type of ETF that are designed to reclassify certain types of income (like foreign income) into other types of income (like domestic income). I get the appeal of something like this, but I’m a little PTSD’d by products that rely on trickery-dickery like this, because we’ve been burned before.

Back in 2015, there were certain mutual funds called “Advantaged funds” that would use forward swap contracts to reclassify interest as capital gains, and I thought “Cool! I want in on some of that!” And then the federal government banned this type of behaviour in 2019, which caused everyone to rush to the exits all at once. We didn’t get hurt too badly since we hadn’t been invested in these funds that long, but since then I steer clear of funds that rely on tax loopholes to function since loopholes can be closed at any point, without warning.

Our solution? Have part of our portfolio invested in Canadian assets, and store those inside our TFSAs. We need Canadian income anyway, and the TSX pays a way higher dividend that the S&P 500, plus Canadian dividends are more tax efficient than foreign dividends.

So our fixed income and domestic equity indexes are Canadian, and our US and international equity indexes are in USD, like so.

Asset Class
ETF
Currency
Fixed Income
BMO Aggregate Bond Index ETF (ZAG)
CAD
Canadian Equity
BMO S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index ETF (ZCN)
CAD
US Equity
Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund ETF (VTI)
USD
International Equity
iShares Core MSCI EAFE ETF (IEFA)
USD
  • Note that currently, the Fixed Income portion has been replaced by a Preferred Share index (ZPR), but normally we hold ZAG for our bond index. See here for more details.

We’ve been asked why we don’t use the same international ETF that we recommend in our workshop (VEU), and the reason is that VEU is the Vanguard All-World Ex-US ETF, which means it invests in world stock market indexes minus the US. That means it also invests in Canada, which duplicates our exposure.

It’s better to hold Canadian stocks as its own ETF since, again, dividends for Canadian dividends are taxed more efficiently for Canadians when held directly. So instead, I want to hold international stocks using the MSCI EAFE Index, which invests in Europe, Australasia, and the Far East. This covers the world markets and gives me the flexibility to place the right ETFs in the right accounts to optimize my taxes, but again, if you’re investing purely in CAD or purely in USD, the investment workshop portfolios will be simpler for you.

In terms of where to hold these ETFs, the TFSAs should be filled up with the Canadian equity ETF. RRSPs should be filled up with bonds and my MSCI EAFE fund, IEFA. Why IEFA and not VTI? IEFA tends to pay a higher dividend, while VTI tends to have higher capital gains, and since capital gains will be taxed as regular income when withdrawn from an RRSP, it’s better to have VTI in a taxable account so you can benefit from the lower tax rate on capital gains.

Once those accounts are filled, everything else, including leftover ZCN and IEFA, goes into the taxable account.

Account Type
ETF
TFSA
BMO S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index ETF (ZCN)
RRSP
BMO Aggregate Bond Index ETF (ZAG), iShares Core MSCI EAFE ETF (IEFA)
Taxable
Everything Left Over

Managing our Cash

Another thing Questrade’s useful for is holding cash. Normally, cash that’s used to pay my day-to-day expenses like rent and groceries should be in a savings account, but because if a lot of your cash is in USD, it’s not always easy to get a decent interest rate on greenbacks in Canada.

Fortunately, you can access another country’s savings accounts by buying an ultra-short treasury bond ETF.

A brief aside on Ultra-short ETFs. “Ultra-short” refers to the average duration of a bond ETF’s underlying investments, which have to be less than 1 year to be considered ultra-short. Money market ETF’s are ultra-short ETFs that exclusively invest in government treasury bills. So the two are related, with the subtle distinction that you can have an ultra-short ETF that isn’t technically money market if they invest in non-government debt, for example, while all money market funds are ultra-short as well.

Ultra-short ETFs are therefore slightly riskier than money market, so they pay a bit more interest. I still consider them to be about as safe as a savings account, since they typically just stick their money into bank savings accounts anyway.

The funds that our reader has mentioned (CASH, PSA, HISU, PSU) are all ultra-short ETFs that are run by different fund companies, and they’re all perfectly fine. Just pick the highest yielding one and stick with it.

And if our CanadianMakingUSD isn’t doing this already, they should definitely read up on Norbert’s Gambit, which is a strategy we use to convert between CAD and USD at the real exchange rate.

It can all be done inside a Questrade account, so when we find ourselves running low on CAD (or if the exchange rate is particularly good), I do the following:

  1. Sell some Ultra-short ETF holdings
  2. Buy DLR
  3. Journal DLR to DLR.U (USD version) by chatting with Questrade’s support team
  4. Sell DLR.U
  5. Withdraw CAD to my checking account
  6. Buy beer

The whole process takes about a week due to settlement times and transfer hold periods.

Oh I took the suggestion of another reader who recommended Interactive Brokers for this, but I found that the hold periods that they imposed way too long for my purposes. If you do a foreign exchange, the platform prevented me from withdrawing for 66 business days! I’ll stick with Questrade.

Conclusion

CanadianEarningUSD also sent us their financial information, which shows they’re hitting a 64% savings rate, so they are doing just fine on that front. Their issue is mostly in how to structure their USD/CAD holdings, so that’s what we’ve focused on in this case study. Once they fixes that, they should be good to go on their dual-currency journey towards FIRE!

How about you? Any interesting tips or tricks you use to manage multiple currencies? Let’s hear it in the comments below!


Hi there. Thanks for stopping by. We use affiliate links to keep this site free, so if you believe in what we're trying to do here, consider supporting us by clicking! Thx ;)

Build a Portfolio Like Ours: Check out our FREE Investment Workshop!

Travel the World: Get flexible worldwide coverage for only $45.08 USD/month with SafetyWing Nomad Insurance

Multi-currency Travel Card: Get a multi-currency debit card when travelling to minimize forex fees! Read our review here, or Click here to get started!

Travel for Free with Home Exchange: Read Our Review or Click here to get started. Please use sponsor code kristy-d61e2 to get 250 bonus points (100 on completing home profile + 150 after first stay)!

24 thoughts on “Reader Case: Canadian making USD”

  1. What about holding VFV (S&P 500 ETF) in a TFSA? I believe it’s a Canadian domiciled ETF so not subject to the 15% withholding tax. Or am I wrong?

    1. When a Canadian domiciled ETF holds U.S securities, the fund itself is subject to the 15% withholding tax on the U.S dividends it receives not the investor. But the year-end returns that the fund publishes are after the taxes have been paid by the fund.

      Since the fund pays the tax, it is better to own it in a non-registered account rather than an RRSP.

      In a non-registered account you will see the tax in Box 34 of the T3 slip and usually get all of it back when you file your tax return. In a few cases I got about 75% rebated.

  2. Like Sirjohnfranklin said, your Norbert’s Gambit steps are backward. Also, Interactive Brokers has extremely cheap currency conversion fees, making the Gambit unnecessary in the first place.

  3. i use cibc investors edge to do the DLR/DLR.U gambit and i found that i could journal directly online without chatting (and on same day as trading day, instead of the next day settlement day). was able to sell the next day (did not try selling the same day as trading day after journaling). so took 3 business days for my executions (Sept 2024).

  4. I was not aware that Corporate Class funds can protect themselves from the 15% withholding tax. Thanks.

    I am very familiar with the benefits of Corporate Class mutual funds and use them for tax efficiency. They have been around for decades — at least since the early 1990’s when I first joined in.

    The only rule that has changed in that time is that you can no longer switch from one fund to another (within the same corporate family of funds) without triggering a capital gain/loss. That change does not matter to me since it is more cumbersome to carry forward the gain/loss of the old fund to the new fund.

    The one problem I have encountered is that some companies (RBC, Franklin-Templeton, Mackenzie(?)) have discontinued them and transferred investors into the regular versions of the funds (Trusts). So they can be a bit difficult to find. That said, Globalx (formerly Horizons) has some ETFs. And Middlefield, Fidelity, CI, Manulife, BMO, and TD have some in the form of mutual funds. Also check out Purpose.

  5. Interactive brokers only holds for 2-3 days for me, and I transfer from CAD checking to IB convert to USD and transfer back to USD account with Royal bank. I have cross boarder banking with Royal bank which gives you a USD credit and USD debit card and pay no fee’s if you hold $1000 in a USD money market account that’s part of cross boarder banking

  6. Discover the perfect blend of style and comfort with Yours Clothing UK. Specializing in footwear and clothing, yours clothing uk offers a diverse range of fashionable options to suit every taste and occasion. From trendy shoes to versatile outfits, their collection caters to all sizes and preferences, ensuring you find exactly what you need to elevate your wardrobe. Shop with confidence at Yours Clothing UK for quality and elegance.

  7. Wanderer, rather than faff around (translates to: mess around) with Norbert’s Gambit, why not just sell the US stock and send the funds to a Wise account, and either spend it from there or move it into your Canadian spending account?

  8. You already have US$ in the TFSA, just buy VTI. It only pays 1.34% in dividends so even if you happen to have $100k invested in VTI, your annual “loss” from those pesky withholding taxes is only about $200 (100k X .0134 X 0.15)!! Not worth the sweat to move stuff around or change back into CND. Not sure if you have an RRSP but you should be able to do “in kind” transfers from the TFSA to the RRSP over time if you really want the VTI to be in the optimal account for US investments.

  9. You mentioned that: “… while VTI tends to have higher capital gains, and since capital gains will be taxed as regular income when withdrawn from an RRSP, it’s better to have VTI in a taxable account so you can benefit from the lower tax rate on capital gains…”

    When you withdraw the RRSP, the funds coming out are all treated as regular income, doesn’t matter the funds came from capital gains or dividend. Am I correct?

  10. The Retises CT Yellow Peel is a popular chemical peel known for its effectiveness in reducing signs of aging and improving skin texture. It helps exfoliate dead skin cells, revealing a smoother and more youthful appearance. When it comes to purchasing, the price of the Retises CT Yellow Peel can vary based on the supplier. For those looking to buy in bulk, you can find it available at competitive rates on sites like retises ct yellow peel price offering a convenient option for skincare professionals.

  11. Any suggestions for US-listed ultra-short ETFs that one can hold at a Canadian brokerage? The only one I can find is BIL.

  12. Look no further than the stunning collection of tagua necklace. Made from sustainably sourced seeds, tagua necklaces are not only eco-friendly but also incredibly stylish. Their vibrant colors and unique textures make them a perfect accessory for any occasion. Whether you’re dressing up for a night out or adding a pop of color to your everyday wardrobe, a tagua necklace is the perfect addition to your jewelry collection. Shop now for the finest selection of necklaces online!

  13. Video games have transformed into a multifaceted form of entertainment, captivating millions worldwide. With genres ranging from action to role-playing, they offer immersive experiences that can transport players to fantastical worlds. As technology advances, the graphics and gameplay become increasingly realistic, enhancing player engagement. Multiplayer modes allow friends and gamers to connect globally, fostering communities around shared interests. Many platforms now feature online betting options, where players can access gaming content more dynamically. For example, you can easily เข้าสู่ระบบ 3xbet to dive into a world of thrilling gaming opportunities and experiences.

  14. In urgent situations, having a reliable emergency plumber can prevent serious damage and stress. When pipes burst, drains clog, or water heaters fail, a professional plumber offers quick and effective solutions. Visit here https://bristol-emergency-plumber.co.uk/ provides 24/7 services for various plumbing issues, ensuring prompt response in emergencies. Immediate assistance can protect your home from extensive water damage and mold growth. Whether it’s a late-night emergency or weekend problem, professional plumbers are equipped to handle any situation efficiently, restoring your plumbing system and peace of mind swiftly and safely.

  15. Very interesting article, thank you for the detailed analysis of the topic! It is always a pleasure to read quality materials that help to look at the problem from a new angle. Good luck with your future writing!

  16. In the event that we have an amount of Canadian dollars and United States dollars that is equal or equivalent (in value, not the actual quantity, according to the conversion rate), would it not be preferable to slope 2 obtain VTI because of the multiple exchange rate? If you are looking at the long term, there is a minimum of five to ten to twenty years.

  17. I really liked how this case study goes beyond the usual investing advice and gets into the messy reality of managing both USD and CAD. The discussion around TFSA, RRSP, withholding taxes, and even the practical side of moving money makes it feel genuinely useful rather than theoretical. I enjoy that same feeling of figuring things out as I go in among us You start with a simple plan, then one unexpected move can completely change your decisions. If you like games that make you think on your feet, give it a few rounds sometime.

  18. Thank you for sharing this inspiring story! It’s fascinating to see how someone’s journey can reshape their financial future. How did they choose which skills to leverage while transitioning to USD?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *