Reader Case: Renters Who Got Duped

Wanderer
Follow Me
Photo by Ivan Samkov @ Pexels.com

Hello!

I always enjoy seeing a fellow Canadian’s Reader Case. Hopefully I’ve got one you’re interested in. I’ve been following your blog for years. I bought your book too! It’s so informative, and I need to dive back in to fix my life but I’m literally stuck at the moment and don’t have access to my possessions. I’m desperate for your help! 

My partner and I are renters. We both have (separate) businesses and while I was earning good money for a period of time, a few things have changed that have impacted my work life. The first is a baby, I’ve definitely had to take a step back from my work to manage things on the daily. The second is the change in the economy. Things have slowed down in my industry. 

Right now we’re in a major jam. Our new rental had mold and we’ve been out of it for months! I’ve had to throw away so many possessions too. Omg I’m screaming inside! We’re at the point of having to re-evaluate trying to rent another home, or because rent is so high, wondering if it makes more sense to purchase a home. One of the takeaways from your book is how I now think of real estate, and I can see how purchasing a home may not be a true investment, but shelter is a necessity and I feel like we’re sinking. I’d love to consider early retirement too and am very worried that if I put all of the money into buying a home, I’m doomed. Please help with your number magic!

Thank you so much,

Sadly Duped


I am so sorry about your situation. Bad landlords are the worst.

The good news is that in Ontario, land lording is an extremely heavily regulated industry, and as any landlord who’s ever tried to evict a bad tenant has learned, the rules are stacked in favour of the tenant. However, most tenants don’t know their rights and tend to assume that whatever the landlord says/does is law. It’s not, but landlords rely on their tenant’s ignorance to get away with shit like this.

Being a successful renter means knowing your rights and how to assert them.

So, let’s see what we can do for our reader shall we?

OK so standard disclaimer here. We are not lawyers, and this is not legal advice. We’re just two bloggers that love sticking it to bad landlords.

Find The Helpers

I sent a follow up email to this reader and received the following:

  1. What city are you in?
    • In the GTA (Greater Toronto Area)
  2. How many months of rent did you prepay and how long ago did your lease start?
    • I paid 6 months upfront per their request. It began on August 1, 2024
  3. Where are you living now?
    • I’m living at my mother’s house with my child. My other half is staying with a colleague due to distance from work.
  4. How much extra are you being forced to pay because of this mold problem and do you have receipts for all these expenses?
    • I have receipts for everything. Currently our out-of-pocket expenses are over $10400 (this doesn’t include some additional costs from my partner). A few examples of costs is an air quality test, 407 bills, gas, monthly parking, and the list goes on

Our story is crazy, and it sounds absolutely insane. If I heard it and wasn’t involved, I would have told the person to stop waiting and get out as quickly as possible. Honestly though, it was a balance of trying to survive, panicking that we would lose all of our money, add a sprinkle of depression, and always being told that we were a week or so away. Overall, I can’t believe we’ve lost 5 months of our lives and our money to this. All we did was move in, and we’re solid tenants who pay their bills and keep things right! Just a terrible situation. 

The first step is always to talk to your landlord and try to resolve the dispute yourself. Clearly, this approach has failed miserably, because SadlyDuped just keeps getting excuses from their landlord and the problem never gets fixed. So, the next step is to find a tenant advocacy group.

These might be run by your city or state/province, but there’s often a group of volunteers or a non-profit that specializes in helping tenants navigate their rights. Here in Canada, it’s the Federation of Metro Tenants Association, or FMTA. They have a hotline you can call to ask questions about your situation.

Another resource that might be useful in this case is the Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario, or ACTO. This is a group funded by the Law Society of Ontario that provides free legal advice to tenants.

Anyone in Canada going through a fight with their landlord should start with these two resources.

Leverage, Leverage, Leverage

Our renter has mentioned that they pre-paid 6 months of rent. That’s actually illegal for the landlord to ask that in Ontario, and the really sucky part is that now that the landlord has our renter’s money, he’s not incentivized to actually fix the damned problem.

So how do we change that?

For starters, we should sic the city on them.

This isn’t one of those issues where the landlord promised an amenity like a laundry machine and didn’t deliver. Mold is a safety issue and falls under city bylaws requiring homeowners to keep their property to a certain standard. That means SadlyDuped should report their landlord to the city’s property standards office.

Using Toronto as an example, you can submit a service request to the city’s RentSafeTO program, which will cause a bylaw enforcement officer to come out and inspect the building. This will do two things. First, it will send the message to your landlord that you mean business. And second, it generates an official record that your building does, in fact, have a mold problem.

This will hopefully light a fire under the landlord’s ass, because once the inspector documents the issue, they’re required to fix it within a certain amount of time. If they keep ignoring the problem, the city will start writing tickets, issuing court summons, and levying fines. And in extreme cases where the landlord digs in their heels and refuses to budge, the city can send someone to fix it and then add the bill to the landlord’s property taxes.

Follow The Money

Then there’s the small matter of the fact that SadlyDuped has lost 6 months of rent, had to replace all their furniture, and is spending money out-of-pocket on alternative accommodations, commuting, etc. So how can they get their money back?

For this, they can make an application to the Landlord Tenant Board.

The LTB is the mediator for landlord/tenant disputes in Ontario. SadlyDuped can apply to the LTB and apply to have their rent returned to them, as well as have the landlord reimburse them for their out-of-pocket costs and ruined furniture.

The big caveat to this is that the LTB is famously backlogged. They’ve gotten better since the pandemic, but scheduling a hearing still takes approximately 6 months. That’s why we want to use the city inspector to help deal with the more immediate mold problem and hopefully allow our renters to move back into their rental. Once their living situation has stabilized, they can then play the long game with the LTB to get their money back.

This is also where their meticulous documentation will come into play. They’ll need to show all of their interactions with their landlord, including when they first informed him that there was mold in the property, and all his repeated attempts to ignore them. The report from the city inspector will also come in super handy, as will all their receipts showing the expenses they were forced to pay because of this issue. The legal clinic from ACTO will be helpful in navigating this process.

If the LTB rules in their favour, the landlord has to pay them the amount claimed. If he continues to ignore them, they can take the judgement to a small claims court and have the judgement enforced, either by taking the money out of his bank account, garnishing his wages, or even putting a lien on his property and potentially foreclosing on him, which would deliciously ironic.

Conclusion

If you’re reading this and thinking “this sounds like a lot of work,” I’m not gonna lie, it is. But you have to remember that just because you own, doesn’t mean that these disputes aren’t going to happen. You aren’t immune to mold just because you bought a home. But as the owner, the responsibility and cost of fixing the issue falls on you. Not only that, the bank’s not going to care if your property isn’t livable. You still have to pay the mortgage or they’re going to take your house. So the problems don’t go away, but as an owner, you are fighting from a position of disadvantage, rather than the other way around.

Have you ever had to fight for your rights as a tenant? If so, how did it go? Let us know in the comments below!


Hi there. Thanks for stopping by. We use affiliate links to keep this site free, so if you believe in what we're trying to do here, consider supporting us by clicking! Thx ;)

Build a Portfolio Like Ours: Check out our FREE Investment Workshop!

Travel the World: Get flexible worldwide coverage for only $45.08 USD/month with SafetyWing Nomad Insurance

Multi-currency Travel Card: Get a multi-currency debit card when travelling to minimize forex fees! Read our review here, or Click here to get started!

Travel for Free with Home Exchange: Read Our Review or Click here to get started. Please use sponsor code kristy-d61e2 to get 250 bonus points (100 on completing home profile + 150 after first stay)!

196 thoughts on “Reader Case: Renters Who Got Duped”

  1. It does sound like a lot of work but the SadlyDuped should do it ASAP. I know with a baby it’s very hard, that’s the thing which boils my blood that how can the landlord even do this. Don’t they have any empathy for this family.

    I truly hope that the Sadly Duped not only gets their money, but also abit more for their troubles.

    1. I had an issue with neighbour who used his house as a rental (later an Air BNB)…There were rats at that house..(I hate those rats)!!!! We actually used to watch them go into their garage, then under the back porch. I had bird feeders, a garden, we took everything away (sadly) as this was a food source for them..Anyways, long story short, we had the City Inspectors & even the local Politicians to help us. They were all great!! Wanted to help us as this was a huge problem.. In the end the home owner had to remedy the problem, he ended up paying some fines as well..The point is to document, document, document!! Use photos, video. This will really help you!

  2. This is sad to hear. There are some amazing landlords out there and some really crappy ones. I’ve dealt with the stuff in the past and the best advice I can give is to get a paralegal involved. Way cheaper than a lawyer and some of them deal with this everyday. Just make sure you get a really highly recommended one.

    I would also highly recommend not moving back into that unit. I’ve seen many situations where mold gets remediated to the point where it passes, but it never truly goes away. If there’s a moisture issue in that unit, the mold will just come back. Not worth taking a chance with the health of your family at stake. This is especially true when there is drywall in the unit. Mold loves drywall and spreads and creates spores at an alarming rate.

  3. With these situations I always know there are two sides to the story then there’s the truth. I’d like to get the landlords side of the story.
    This story sets out why I would never want to help people with housing and be a landlord.
    The government shirks their responsibility of helping with housing and downloads it onto the back of landlords.
    The governments have so many regulations, taxes, fees that always benefit renters and not the small investor trying to help people with housing.
    The government assumes being a landlord is a charity to benefit tenants.
    Tenants and leftist politicians deliberately never understand that the landlord has to pay hyperinflating taxes, insurance, utilities, property taxes, carbon taxes , tenants that don’t pay, repair costs and upkeep.
    It would be hilarious if all small landlords went on strike and would stop renting. The result would be hundreds of thousands of people homeless on the street destitute. The government would be responsible for housing them and would go to begging landlords to help.
    I’m happy with just buying REITs and let them deal with the unending risks and aggravation of being a landlord and enforcing legally binding tenant contracts

    1. There is something to be said about “tenant friendly” laws actually backfiring on tenants. These kinds of laws tend to be most stringent in high cost areas. In my opinion, they’re a band-aid that never fixes the underlying problem, which is typically a chronic lack of housing supply. The housing supply problem is created by rich NIMBYs who say things like “We know there’s a need for housing BUT…..(fill in the blank with excuses as to why there can’t be any new housing built in THEIR neighborhood. Wash, rinse, repeat in neighborhood after neighborhood).

      The best fix for bad landlords is an abundant supply of housing. When people have housing options, it keeps landlords in check. Government bureaucracy and “tenant friendly” laws will always be inadequate, at best. At worst, it exacerbates the problem instead of making it better, all while giving renters the illusion that the government is looking out for them.

      1. “The best fix for bad landlords is an abundant supply of housing. When people have housing options, it keeps landlords in check. Government bureaucracy and “tenant friendly” laws will always be inadequate, at best.”

        Yes, that. Upvote here!

  4. I enjoy playing video games immensely. I can only unwind after a day of labor in this manner. I wish to immerse myself in the game and appreciate its enchanted universe. Therefore, many thanks for the game lol beans. You suggested.

  5. Industrial racking installation is essential for maximizing storage space and improving warehouse efficiency. Properly installed racking systems ensure safety, organization, and easy access to materials. Businesses rely on expert installation to meet industry standards and support heavy loads. Factors like weight capacity, space optimization, and durability play a crucial role in the process. Professional installers assess warehouse layouts and install racks securely to prevent accidents. A well-executed industrial racking installation enhances workflow, reduces clutter, and boosts productivity, making it a vital investment for any industrial facility.

  6. The fact that there are two sides to a story and then there is the truth is something that I am always conscious of. I am interested in hearing the viewpoint of the landlord. google baseball

  7. A Frosty Adventure Geometry Dash SubZero
    Geometry Dash Subzero features three levels, each with its own unique difficulty, theme, and set of challenges. These levels are designed to test your reflexes and ability to adapt to rapid changes in the game’s pace, all while maintaining synchronization with the music. Let’s break down each level:

  8. Whether you’re relocating across town or just a few blocks away, searching for moving companies near me ensures quick access to trusted professionals. These companies often provide packing, loading, and transport services tailored to your needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *