Trump Accounts: Are They a Scam?

Wanderer
Follow Me
Photo by The Jopwell Collection on Unsplash

When I first heard about the Trump accounts, my first questions were: Is this a trick? Is this a scam? Is this thing designed to steal people’s money and put it into TrumpCoin?

And apparently, I wasn’t alone. According to a survey by BuildCommonWealth.org, since Trump accounts became available to the public this summer, only 5% of eligible parents in that survey had opened one. The top concerns parents had were:

  • They didn’t understand how it worked
  • They didn’t have spare money to contribute to it
  • They didn’t trust Trump or anything with his name on it

All valid concerns. Clearly, the branding on the Trump account hasn’t been great. However, I think that judging an account purely based on the name is a mistake. If you want to, you can refer to it by it’s formal name, which is a 530A account.

However, the bigger problem seems to be that people don’t understand how it works, because you don’t actually need to put money into it to get a benefit. So let’s pull back the curtain on this thing and see what it actually does.

How It Works

The Trump/530A account is a tax-advantaged account that can be opened on behalf of any child with a valid Social Security Number, so this includes US citizens, permament residents, and legal visa holders.

Children who are specifically US citizens born between Jan 1, 2025 and Dec 31, 2028 are also eligible for a one-time grant of $1000 from the US government.

Contributions

Families can voluntarily contribute up to $5000 per year. Contributions are after-tax, meaning you won’t get a tax deduction for contributing, similar to a Roth IRA.

Corporations can also contribute up to $2500 annually per employee to their Trump account. Several companies, like Dell computers and IBM, have already said they plan on offering this as part of their employee benefits packages.

Interestingly, employer contributions are treated differently than your own contributions. Money taken off your paycheck is pre-tax like a 401(k) contribution, while money you put in on your own is after-tax.

Tax Treatment

Right now, funds are limited to investing in low-cost index funds that track the US stock market, with a restrictions fund expenses to less than 0.1%.

Investment gains, in the form of dividends or capital gains, are not taxed while held in the account, similar to an IRA.

Withdrawals

No withdrawals are allowed until the child turns 18, at which point the account essentially morphs into a Traditional IRA, with all the normal rules associated with them. Withdrawals will be taxed in the child’s hands, and may be subject to early withdrawal penalties if done before the age of 59 ½.

The Power Of Compounding

What I like the most about the Trump account is that it actually forces investors to do the right thing by restricting the investments to low-cost index funds. A Trump account, if opened when a child is first born, will have an investment timeline of 18 years. Over rolling 18-year time horizons, the S&P 500 has NEVER lost money, and has historically returned between a 5% and 18%, with a median performance of about 11%.

That means with the initial seed money of $1000, by the time the child turns 18, here’s what their account will be worth based on the stock market returns they actually experience.

As you can see, that $1000 will grow to between $2400 (5% returns) to nearly $20,000 (18% returns), with a median of about $6500 (11% returns).

Remember the first rule of personal finance: Never turn down free money.

Trump vs 529

I think the biggest point of confusion about the Trump account is how it compares to another similar tax-advantaged vehicle for children: The 529 account.

529 accounts are used to save for a child’s tuition, and many of the rules are similar.

529
Trump/530A
Contributions
After-Tax
After-Tax (parent’s contributions)
Investment Options
More choices
US equity index fund only
Investment Taxes
Not Taxed
Not Taxed
Withdrawals @ Age 18
Tax-Free for eligible education expenses
Taxed in hands of child

That last bit is the big difference between the 529 and Trump account. In Trump account marketing materials, they advertise the ability to take out money without penalty when the child turns 18 to pay for education or a home purchase, but that’s without the 10% early-withdrawal penalty. The child still has to declare the withdrawals as ordinary income and potentially pay taxes on that.

The 529, on the other hand, explicitly allows tax-free withdrawals for education. So for the specific purpose of saving for a child’s education, the 529 is better. The contribution limits are higher, there’s more flexibility on what you can invest in, and most importantly, withdrawals are tax-free.

Should You Open One?

Earlier this month, in response to the embarrassingly low enrollment numbers for the Trump account, the government automatically enrolled every eligible child on their behalf. So congratulations! Your child already has a Trump account WHETHER THEY WANT ONE OR NOT.

Parents still have to download the app and claim their child’s $1000, though, so everyone with a child born between Jan 1, 2025 and Dec 31, 2028 should definitely do that. There’s no down side, and remember: Never turn down free money.

The Trump account is also useful for receiving employer contributions if your employer has that as part of their benefits package. Those contributions are pre-tax, so it’s more similar to how the 401k/Traditional IRA operates.

However, for parents wanting to put their own money into this to save for their child’s education, I would give this a pass. Trump accounts are too restrictive (you can’t withdraw money for any reason before the child turns 18), there’s no flexibility in what you can invest in, and most importantly, your child gets taxed when they withdraw the money. The 529 is a far better vehicle for this, as education-related withdrawals are tax-free.

Conclusion

So now that we understand the Trump account a little better, it’s clear that the best way to use it is to simply open one up (or rather, claim your already opened account) by going to TrumpAccounts.gov and downloading the app. Get your $1000 from the government, throw it into the S&P 500, and then just let it compound.

If your company has any matching program as part of their employee benefits package, take advantage of that, because never turn down free money. But other than that, I don’t see any compelling reason to put any additional money into a Trump account since other accounts like the 529, Roth IRA, and even the UGMA have better terms, are less restrictive, and most importantly, don’t tax your withdrawals.

So even if you don’t trust this administration, even if you don’t have any extra money to spare, you should still open one of these since you don’t have to put in any of your own money. Use it to take the government’s money.

So, in the end, who’s scamming who?


Guess what? The Toronto Star featured our book Parent Like a Millionaire (Without Being One) this week, and I was especially happy to see them link to the free calculators we built for parents!

Parenting already comes with enough decisions and not enough time, so we built these free calculators to do some of the math for you. You can plug in your own numbers and decide what works best for your family.


Hi there. Thanks for stopping by. We use affiliate links to keep this site free, so if you believe in what we're trying to do here, consider supporting us by clicking! Thx ;)

Build a Portfolio Like Ours: Check out our FREE Investment Workshop!

Travel the World: Get flexible worldwide coverage for only $45.08 USD/month with SafetyWing Nomad Insurance

Multi-currency Travel Card: Get a multi-currency debit card when travelling to minimize forex fees! Read our review here, or Click here to get started!

Travel for Free with Home Exchange: Read Our Review or Click here to get started. Please use sponsor code kristy-d61e2 to get 250 bonus points (100 on completing home profile + 150 after first stay)!

30 thoughts on “Trump Accounts: Are They a Scam?”

  1. Trump is the worst person and president ever, we stand with you Canada… That said, these accounts are great and he deserves credit for the few positive things he has done.

    1. Thanks, we appreciate your support. We all have 2 more years to get through, so let’s get through it together.

      The origin of the Trump accounts is its own story too. Apparently, the idea came from Ted Cruz of all people, because he believed that young people were too enamored with socialism and these accounts were meant to promote capitalism. It got Trump’s blessing on the condition that they name the thing after him, and then it got passed as part of the One Big Beautiful Bill last year.

      Not sure this was enough to offset all the damage the OBBB did, but at this point I’ll take any good news I can get

  2. I got my son a Trump account and I despise the man. Most of the people that I talk to don’t want to do because Trump’s name is attached to it. To me that is extremely short-sighted. My son got the $250 deposit from the Dell foundation, not the $1000 because he was born in 2018. That said I think it is important to get that “Free money” and future free monies. I invest $1 a day for him everyday. Plus, I have a 529 account. I know many have said that Trump accounts could count against financial aid, but that is a small sacrifice for my son to get a financial leg up.

    1. Good job. The name is unfortunate, but free money is free money.

      As for the Trump account counting against financial aid, the jury’s still out on that one. IRAs are not counted as assets for FAFSA, but then again this account is brand new, so who knows?

      Either way, don’t make decisions based on what future changes might happen. If there’s money on the table now, take it.

  3. I would also note that Michael and Susan Dell are donating $250 to eligible children 10 and under (born 2016-2024). So in line with the philosophy of not turning down free money, I opened accounts for my kids and they were funded with the $250 at the beginning of September. There is a median income requirement of your zip code. For more information: https://investamerica.org/dell/

    1. I can confirm this, my 8 year old twins (born in 2016) got $250 in their accounts. I don’t plan to do anything with these accounts other then opening them, and letting any govt/sponsored money go in. I already have UGMA and 529 accounts for them. Putting money in the trump account will just dillute the investing power of their existing accounts.

  4. Too bad to much Trump Derangement Syndrome in this group, people would rather have mass invasion then borders, go look at what’s happening to Europe.
    Enough said you’re all watching too much main stream media!

    1. I am European and travel quite often to the US for work. I can tell you that by far the US is much more dangerous than any place in Europe. Instead of believing any BS you are fed just come and have a look to the reality of Europe. I am always amazed by how much people can be brainwashed in the US

  5. Wanderer’s TDS is palpable. Not to mention the rest of the comments. I love how everyone rushed to sign up for the free money though. Hypocrites.

  6. “There’s no down side, and remember: Never turn down free money.”

    I have to disagree with this. The only reason for stipulating the installation of their phone app is to collect sensitive location and user data for his cronies to later resell and/or register in an ICE database for later use against the public. Knowing everything they have done so far, my privacy is worth far more than $1k + the compounded returns.

  7. The stat that really stuck with me is the 5% enrollment — it shows the real barrier isn’t the tax math, it’s the branding and the confusion, which your 529 comparison drives home. People are so put off by the name that they’re leaving $1000 of their own kid’s seed money on the table, which honestly feels like cutting off your nose to spite your face. For anyone on the fence: claiming it costs nothing, and 18 years of compounding on the free seed is the entire point.

  8. Understanding the fees, eligibility requirements, and long-term benefits of financial programs is essential before making investment decisions. Similarly, building healthy habits takes a practical approach, and compound movement exercises can help make workouts more efficient by targeting multiple muscle groups at once.

  9. I see the irony you highlight, Trump’s polarizing legacy paired with the account scheme allegedly seeded by Ted Cruz through the One Big Beautiful Bill. What strikes me is how the Miami Dade Community often mirrors these national debates, turning policy quirks into everyday conversation. Your call for solidarity over the next two years feels resonant, showing that even divisive symbols can unite us for endurance. Staying honest in this dialogue is essential if we hope to measure any real progress.

  10. Your breakdown of how the Trump accounts originated from a Cruz idea and slipped into the One Big Beautiful Bill captures the odd mix of ideology and branding that many millennials find baffling, especially when you note we only have two years left to navigate it together. Orange County Clerk illustrates how even seemingly unrelated initiatives can hinge on clear record keeping and public accountability. It’s a reminder that any platform promising transparency must be scrutinized, and your cautious optimism about any positive spin feels refreshingly realistic.

  11. Your skepticism about the Trump-branded accounts feels justified, especially given the opaque funding trail you describe and the political maneuvering that began with Ted Cruz’s proposal; the mixture of idealistic rhetoric and questionable deposits mirrors many grassroots scams that thrive on vague promises. When evaluating such claims, digging into official documentation can reveal the truth, and a reliable source for that in Florida is the Hillsborough Legal Records database, which offers searchable, court-verified details. Ultimately, demanding transparent evidence protects both parents and their children from unintended financial entanglements.

  12. Your rundown of the Trump account origin, Ted Cruz’s push, the One Big Beautiful Bill, and the uneasy capitalist spin, captures the confusion many feel. Applying the same scrutiny you’d use to verify a financial scheme to official data, such as a Riverside County Taxes search, often reveals hidden obligations before you commit. That habit of cross‑checking public records mirrors the transparency we demand from local government, where open court dockets and filings deter fraud. Stay vigilant and the community will cut through the hype faster than another campaign promise.

  13. I think it’s important to look beyond the headlines and understand how these accounts actually work. The eligibility rules, fees and long term benefits are all worth examining before making any delicious!

  14. The part about having no boss, no commute and no home, yet still not feeling fully free, stuck with me. I’ve noticed something similar with travel. The trips that felt best weren’t the ones with zero obligations, but the ones where I took on a small responsibility, like bringing my dog along. It changes how you plan everything from flights to rest stops, and a solid dog-travel-crate made those trips far less stressful for both of us.

  15. The comparison with a 529 is the most useful part of this discussion. Could you add a side-by-side example using the same contribution dates, return assumptions and fees, then show the different withdrawal scenarios separately? That would help readers distinguish the account rules from the compounding assumptions. Disclosure: I run CriptoCompara, a Brazilian financial comparison website; this is a question about the comparison method, not a recommendation to open either account.

  16. This was a realaly helpful breakdown. I thinks a lot of people are getting caught up in th name without fully understanding how the account works about Geometry Dash Polargeist. Looking at the actual rules and benefits makes it much easier to evaluable!

  17. Your breakdown of the Trump account saga, from the Cruz‑inspired proposal to the One Big Beautiful Bill, captures the uneasy mix of political intent and personal skepticism. In that spirit, a reliable resource such as Minnesota Plate Registration offers the same straightforward verification many of us crave when sorting through opaque narratives. Just as you urge separating policy from a polarizing name, vehicle owners benefit from separating legal duties from confusing paperwork. A clear plate lookup can prevent costly errors and keep focus on the bigger picture you’re fighting for.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *